Untitled
www.aidsmap.comissue 158 july 2006
why GPs need to be integrated into HIV-positive care page 4
primary care at HIV clinics
is your clinic providing GP services? page 14
immunisation guidelines
new vaccination guidance for HIV-positive people page 8
does efavirenz cause depression?
a new study suggests otherwise page 3
anti-HIV therapy adds thirteen years to post-AIDS survival page 13
LGV continues to spread amongst HIV-positive gay men page 13
aids treatment update july 2006
Some GPs have never been exposed to
page 3 This month's Upfront asks whether
diagnosed HIV-positive patients because in
efavirenz (Sustiva) is the primary cause of
the past, HIV clinics have made it easy for
depression in people taking this anti-HIV
us to use them as a one-stop-shop, negating
drug, since a new study from France suggests
our need for a GP.
that other factors may be to blame.
This has led to a vicious circle that needs to
page 4 In Better practice, we explain why
GPs need to be integrated into HIV-positive
be broken because some GPs continue to miss
care, and examine the barriers - and possible
undiagnosed HIV, since they're not HIV-aware.
solutions - to this uniquely British problem.
Besides, sooner or later, we will all require an
page 8 Dr Anna Maria Geretti, lead author
HIV-knowledgeable GP, because GPs will need
of the the most comprehensive immunisation
to prescribe medicines that your HIV clinic can
guidelines ever produced for HIV-positive
no longer afford - like lipid-lowering and
adults, explains why HIV-positive people
anti-diabetes drugs, and antidepressants.
need special consideration when it comes
If you have a GP that already knows about
to vaccinations.
HIV issues, you probably live in an area
page 12 News in Brief features a calculation
where your local Primary Care Trust (PCT)
that anti-HIV therapy adds more than
provides the 'carrot' of locally enhanced
thirteen years to post-AIDS survival. Plus
services. This means GPs get paid extra to
further details of the current LGV outbreak
provide good quality care for HIV-positive
in the UK that is disproportionately affecting
people. Sadly, many need this financial
HIV-positive gay men; why anyone on triple
enticement in order to learn more about HIV
NRTI therapy should consider changing to
and take on HIV-positive patients.
something more potent; and news about a
potentially serious heart condition that
We need to put pressure on our local PCTs
affects one in every 200 HIV-positive people.
to provide locally enhanced services in every
area, but until that utopia exists, why not ask
page 14 Is your HIV clinic providing GP
services? Compare their policies to the six
your clinic, or other HIV-positive people, to
UK clinics who answered our snapshot survey
help you find a local GP that is HIV-aware.
regarding the provision of primary care at
HIV clinics.
medical advisory panel
NAM is a charity that exists to
The publishers have taken all such
support the fight against HIV and
care as they consider reasonable in
Professor Janet Darbyshire
AIDS with independent, accurate,
preparing this newsletter. But they
aids treatment update
Heather Leake Date MRPharmS
up-to-date and accessible
will not be held responsible for any
editor Edwin J Bernard
information for affected
inaccuracies or mis-statements of
sub-editing & proofreading
Professor Brian Gazzard
communities, and those working to
fact contained herein. Inclusion in
Professor Frances Gotch
support them.
this newsletter of information on
production Thomas Paterson
Dr Margaret Johnson
any drug or clinical trial in no
design Alexander Boxill
For more information, and details
way represents an endorsement of
printing Cambrian Printers
Dr Adrian Palfreeman
of our other publications and
that drug or trial. This newsletter
Kholoud Porter PhD
services, please contact us, or visit
should always be used in
copyright NAM Publications
our website, www.aidsmap.com.
conjunction with professional
2006 All rights reserved
Professor Jonathan Weber
medical advice.
charity number 1011220
AIDS Treatment Update
For more information about ATU's
was founded by Peter Scott
medical review panel, please visitwww.aidsmap.com/atu.
contact details Lincoln House, 1 Brixton Road,
London, SW9 6DE, UK
email: [email protected]
The Derek Butler Trust
aids treatment update july 2006
Does efavirenz cause depression?
by Edwin J Bernard
Efavirenz (Sustiva) is one of the most
similar people who continued to take
popular anti-HIV drugs in the UK and,
their PI-based treatment combination.
out of all the non-nucleosides
During the first year of the study, a
(NNRTIs) or protease inhibitors (PIs)
similar number of people taking either
available, it is the drug that people
efavirenz or a PI were diagnosed with
starting therapy for the first time are
depression. Although more people on
most likely to take.
efavirenz experienced side-effects bad
Although it is well established that the
enough to switch away from the drug,
most common side-effects of efavirenz
this was due to bad dreams, dizziness
occur in the central nervous system,
and headaches, and no-one stopped
and studies have shown that up to
treatment because of depression.
50% can experience side-effects
In fact, rather than efavirenz being
efavirenz-based regimens resulted in
relating to sleep disturbance during the
linked to depression, the investigators
excess anxiety or depression," the
first few months of treatment, there
found that both younger age and a
have been conflicting findings on the
previous bout of depression were
link between efavirenz and the
linked to a greater risk of developing
Nevertheless, last year a small study
development of depression.
depression during the study, regardless
from Spain found that people who
continue to experience efavirenz's
Some clinical trials have found that
of which anti-HIV drugs they were
psychological side-effects in the longer
the psychiatric side-effects of efavirenz
taking. "Contrary to the idea widely
term are much more likely to have
– including depression, suicidal
held among HIV-infected patients,
physicians, and researchers, our data
higher than normal levels of the drug
thoughts, aggression, paranoia, and
showed no evidence of efavirenz
in their blood. Individuals with a blood
mania – are very rare. Depression has
having an effect on the risk of
plasma concentration of efavirenz
been reported in around 2% of people
depression or suicide in the first 48
above 2.74µg/ml at any point during
on efavirenz and other psychiatric
weeks of use – or even up to 36
the 18 month study were almost six
side-effects have been reported in
months of use," the researchers wrote.
times more likely to develop
fewer than 1% of people on the drug.
side-effects that included depression or
Around one person in every hundred
A study published last November
sleeping problems than those with
discontinued efavirenz due to
attempted to examine efavirenz's
consistently lower blood levels.
psychiatric side-effects. However, other
side-effects in a different way, by
studies have found higher rates of
monitoring the drug's psychological
Some people clear efavirenz more
depression in people taking efavirenz.
effects in a ‘blinded' study, in which the
slowly than others due to a particular
303 participants did not know which
genetic variation. This genetic variation
Adding to the body of evidence against
drugs they were taking. Again, the
is common among people with a black
the link between efavirenz and
study's investigators saw no differences
African heritage and it may increase the
depression is a new study from France,
in the levels of anxiety or depression
risk of efavirenz-related side-effects.
published in June. This study examined
between the 200 participants on
Testing is not currently available to find
the effects of switching 178 people
efavirenz and the 103 not on efavirenz.
out who has this particular genetic
from an anti-HIV treatment
make-up. However, therapeutic drug
combination that included a PI, to a
"We provided a controlled, systematic
monitoring may be used to identify
combination that included efavirenz.
evaluation of efavirenz on anxiety and
people who are being exposed to high
The outcomes were compared with 177
depression and found no evidence that
concentrations of efavirenz.
aids treatment update july 2006
In the 25 years since what is now
these discrimination issues early on by
and it is now their strategy to involve
known as AIDS was first described in
placing HIV testing within the free and
primary care in sexual health and HIV
a group of gay men in California and
confidential GUM (genito-urinary
services. The problem, however, is that
New York, for many people living in
medicine, or sexual health) clinic.
most GPs are not adequately
developed nations like the United
When it became available, HIV
experienced or skilled in complementing
Kingdom, an HIV diagnosis has
treatment was provided in these
sexual health and HIV specialist care.
evolved from a death sentence into a
GUM clinics and other specialties,
complex chronic condition.
Nevertheless, some of our healthcare
like Infectious Diseases, became
needs – including general care for
involved, and, therefore, many doctors
Constantly-evolving monitoring and
non-HIV related conditions and care
treatment are not the only reasons why
in general practice (GPs, who provide
relating to HIV that sits naturally in
HIV is a complex disease. Since HIV is
primary care) had limited exposure to
general practice (e.g. facilitating
also primarily a sexually transmissable
patients with HIV.
referral to mental health services in the
condition and is also an unfolding global
In the 21st century, however, it is clear
community) – may be better managed
event – with legal, social and political
that both GUM clinics and HIV
at a GP's surgery rather than at an
implications – it is further complicated
specialist services are struggling to
HIV clinic. And there may be new roles
by prejudice, stigma and discrimination.
meet demand. The government believes
for HIV-educated GPs to play in the
The UK's National Health Service
that the obvious place to relieve some
future (e.g. the routine monitoring of
(NHS) attempted to deal with some of
of this pressure is in general practice,
CD4 counts and viral load).
aids treatment update july 2006
Why do we need a GP?
the British HIV Association (BHIVA),
or have only mild symptoms of HIV
at the symposium. "Therefore GPs are
infection. And for people with advanced
Until now, many HIV-positive people
going to have to be involved, and that
HIV disease, GPs are invaluable in
have been able to use their HIV clinic
means we need to make sure all of our
helping to provide home support in
not just for HIV care, but also for
patients have GPs [by then]".
association with specialist community
general health issues. Many clinics
care teams and nurses.
currently provide prescriptions for
There is absolutely no possibility,
things that are definitely not HIV-
however, that GPs will take over all
William Ford-Young, who describes
related (like flu vaccines, or asthma
HIV care - at least for the foreseeable
himself as "a pragmatic 'coal-face' GP,
medicine) although some are beginning
future. "I think we're a long away from
with an interest in the GP's role in HIV
to limit their prescribing to anti-HIV
GPs routinely prescribing
management and support" is one of
antiretroviral therapy," Martin Fisher,
two GPs on the government's
HIV consultant at Brighton and
Independent Advisory Group on Sexual
Whatever the situation in your clinic
Sussex University Hospital, told the
Health & HIV, and is also Chair of the
(and London HIV clinics are already
NAM symposium. "Maybe in ten years
Royal College of General Practitioners
under pressure to save money this year
but not in the next few years."
(RCGP) Task Group for Sex, Drugs &
due to only a 5% increase in funding
HIV. He argues that all HIV-positive
despite at least a 10% increase in
And Judy Hague, HIV programme
people can really benefit from having a
patients) their prescribing policies will
director of the London Specialised
GP, regardless of the kind of care they
probably have to change in 2008.
Commissioning Group confirmed that
receive at their local HIV clinic.
That's when a new NHS funding
"the case for HIV remaining a
system known as payment by results
specialised service is a strong one.
"My feeling, as a GP, is that GPs have
promises to radically alter how
People with HIV may have other
tremendous skill and experience and a
HIV-positive patients get services, and
health problems, and will require
whole team at their fingertips to
how HIV outpatient clinics get paid for
access to a balance of services
provide ongoing care for people with
providing them (for more on this see
[including GPs] but I don't personally
chronic conditions," he says. "Certainly,
Does cost matter? in ATU 150;
anticipate that HIV care will move
people need a specialist for the
October 2005).
outside of specialised services [i.e. the
complicated HIV issues like
HIV clinic]".
In May, NAM held a one-day clinical
symposium to discuss issues around the
What can GPs do for us?
future of HIV treatment. Part of the
There are several reasons why
afternoon session focused on accessing
registering with a GP and telling them
care in the context of NHS overspends,
of your HIV status may be beneficial.
cost-cutting and payment by results;
The GP's surgery should be more
how increasing HIV diagnoses are
accessible and may be open in the
overburdening already stretched HIV
evening for appointments. Unlike
clinics (which provide secondary care);
HIV physicians, GPs can visit you
and how GPs can be better integrated
at home and you can also access
into the care of HIV-positive people.
a doctor for emergency visits
after hours via your GP. They
"With payment by results we will no
are an alternative to the
longer be able to act as GPs and refer
specialist clinics for sorting out
our patients to another specialty, for
and treating general problems for
example to get a hip replacement,"
people who are largely asymptomatic
noted Dr Margaret Johnson, Chair of
why GPs need to be integrated into hiv-positive care by Edwin J Bernard
aids treatment update july 2006
therapeutics, virology and immunology.
sufficient knowledge [about HIV]. We
clinic, and presented to the BHIVA
But I think GPs are good at doing
have to get over these barriers and
Conference this March, found that 85
things that HIV specialists possibly
make sure GPs get involved."
out of 1687 patients (5%) had
aren't good at; we can manage many of
experienced HIV-related discrimination
Understandably, this is causing a lot of
the things that go hand-in-hand with
from their GP in the past[1]; gay men
anxiety, not just amongst HIV-positive
chronic disease: the psycho-social
were much more likely to have
people and the community groups that
issues; the relationship difficulties; the
experienced this discrimination than
advocate for and support them, but also
mental health-related things, like
African men and women.
amongst many GPs and HIV physicians.
depression; and the way that a chronic
Since December 2005, the Disability
disease can generally affect your
So far, however, no clear policy has
Discrimination Act has protected
feeling of well-being. These are things
emerged regarding who will lead this
that good GPs deal with all the time."
anyone diagnosed HIV-positive from
integration of GPs into HIV-positive
being discriminated against in a
people's care. For example, neither the
Steven Ash, HIV consultant at Ealing
healthcare setting, since they are
DoH, nor the NHS, nor many of the
Hospital, in west London, agrees that
providing services (one of the areas
leading bodies involved in either
"there are some problems patients may
covered under the Act). It is, therefore,
specialist HIV care or general practice
have that are better dealt with by a
unlawful for GPs not to provide the
- including the RCGP, BHIVA, the
GP, and patients miss out if they do not
same services to an HIV-positive
make use of a GP service."
British Association of Sexual Health
person that they provide to
and HIV (BASHH) and the British
HIV-negative people, or to discriminate
Barriers to integration
Medical Association (BMA) - have
in the standard of service or the terms
"It comes down to the right patient
agreed on how best to educate GPs
on which the service is provided.
seeing the right doctor for the right
thing," said Martin Fisher at the NAM
However, the law cannot change
symposium, but he added that "there
attitudes overnight, and there still does
are a lot of barriers" to the integration
We are now in the unfortunate
appear to be a lot of concern from
of HIV into primary care. "Some of
situation where the people who have
HIV-positive people over another, related
those barriers are with the GPs, who
lived with HIV for the longest time
issue: a perceived lack of confidentiality,
are scared about HIV," he said. "Then
have the least trust in GPs. This is
particularly around informing third
there are problems with secondary
likely because most of the people
parties - e.g. employers, insurance
care. I think we're a bit too precious
initially affected by HIV in the
companies - about their HIV status. This
and not very good at letting go, and I
UK - gay men, injecting drug users and
continues to be a common reason given
think we need to. And then I think
sex workers, all of whom were
by HIV-positive people for not involving
there are barriers around patients
marginalised from society - often
being scared of their GPs having
experienced prejudice, stigma and
discrimination from their GPs during
For example, Ealing's Steven Ash tells
the Thatcherite 1980s and early 1990s.
ATU that "around 10% of our
patients have no GP. Another 30% do
In fact, a survey undertaken last year
not allow us to communicate with
at a north-east London HIV outpatient
their GP, and the GP is therefore
unaware of their diagnosis."
William Ford-Young says that
although in the past he's heard some
horror stories about issues such as a
lack of respect for confidentiality,
things have much improved. And
where they haven't, "it's important
that patients, and patients'
organisations, challenge wherever they
are finding bad practice."
Better communication needed"HIV remains the only condition
whereby you can go from your diagnosis
to your death without your GP ever
aids treatment update july 2006
knowing about it," notes Dr Ford-Young.
through no fault of their own," he told
expecting GPs to provide HIV care,"
"In this day and age, that's appalling."
the NAM symposium.
explains Martin Fisher, "we're expecting
the GPs to provide the primary care for
One of the problems is that the 1974
Enhancing services
people who also happen to have HIV."
Venereal Disease Regulations - which
Happily, many individuals and
provide for strict confidentiality within
organisations are beginning to work
Education is the solution
the GUM clinic - may be preventing
together to try to find solutions to
Surinder Singh, a south-east London
good and clear communication
these problems.
GP with a special interest in HIV, and
between HIV clinicians and GPs and
the second GP on the government's
we, as patients, are often caught in
The Medical Foundation for AIDS and
Independent Advisory Group on Sexual
the crossfire.
Sexual Health (MedFASH) - a charity
Health & HIV, noted at the NAM
supported by the BMA - recommended
symposium there is "great variability
At the moment, HIV physicians can
that all people with HIV should have
with where locally enhanced services
only keep a patient's GP informed of
access to good quality GP care
are available."
medication and other important
encompassing prevention, diagnosis,
treatment information if the patient
treatment and care as part of their
These services are funded by individual
gives them permission to do so.
'Recommended standards for NHS
PCTs and, thanks to the government's
However, the simple act of asking for
HIV Services', published in October
decentralised funding of NHS services,
permission may create unnecessary
2003 and endorsed by the Department
funding decisions are left to the
anxiety, and suggests that there is
of Health (DoH). A year later, they
discretion of these PCTs. "So in south
something inherently wrong in the GP
produced an excellent booklet, HIV in
east London we don't have any,"
having this information. Like any
successful relationship, good
communication can remove
uncertainty, mistrust and fear.
Dr Ford-Young's RCGP Task Group has
been trying to improve communications
between GPs and HIV physicians for
several years. "I think the waters have
got very muddied with secondary care
primary care, aimed at educating
providing a primary care service for a
GPs about myriad HIV issues - from
continues Dr Singh,
lot of HIV-positive patients," he says.
HIV tests to drug-drug interactions.
"and that doesn't seem all that
"To help remedy that, we are working
equitable. The patient should
on processes of safe communication,
Later this month, BHIVA is hosting a
safe prescribing, and sorting out who's
one-day workshop comprising many
responsible for doing what," he says.
HIV professionals, representatives from
Dr Ford-Young agrees, but argues that
"We're working quite hard to make
the DoH and Primary Care Trusts
HIV-positive people don't necessarily
sure that HIV-positive people can have
(PCTs), and many patient advocate
need a locally enhanced service to get
good GPs, but obviously this only works
organisations, including NAM. Focusing
the best from their GP. "The bottom
well if GPs are aware of their patient's
primarily on how best to improve
line is that if you have a good quality
HIV status."
access to HIV care throughout the UK,
general practice - and that's not just
it will also include a discussion of how
the GP, but the whole team - things
Brighton's Martin Fisher agrees
GPs can best be integrated into the
work well for patients with HIV no
communication must improve - not just
care of HIV-positive people.
matter who they are or how they've
between GPs and HIV physicians, but
acquired their HIV infection. And those
also between HIV-positive people and
And in several areas of the country,
issues shouldn't have to arise because
GPs. "It's important to have that
GPs are being educated about HIV at
GPs should be good for everybody.
dialogue with GPs because if we don't
locally-run workshops. In Brighton,
involve them, and if the patient doesn't
they've been running an interactive
"I know that that's an ideal, and it's
tell them, they're not going to know
two-day HIV education course for
important to recognise that there are
what medications we've prescribed and
interested GPs and their practice
gaps between the ideal and reality. But
that could lead to GPs prescribing
nurses since 2004, resulting in at least
educating GPs about HIV, educating
drugs that interact, or change a drug
eight GP practices in Brighton and
patients about GPs, and creating a
we've prescribed, like a statin [lipid-
Hove providing what is known as
much better dialogue between the
lowering drugs, many of which can
locally enhanced services for
specialists and general practitioners
interact with anti-HIV medicines],
HIV-positive people. "We're not
can close that gap."
aids treatment update july 2006
Why HIV-positive people need special
consideration when it comes to vaccinations,
by Edwin J Bernard
After more than a year in the making, themost comprehensive immunisationguidelines ever produced for HIV-positiveadults are now available to download foran extended consultation period from theBritish HIV Association website[1]. Theywill be revised based on feedback receivedby mid-September, and the final guidelineswill then be published in HIV Medicine.
Compared with our HIV-negative
counterparts, HIV-positive people may
have an increased risk of infection, or
experience more severe disease, following
exposure to vaccine-preventable diseases.
The guidelines cover in detail how the risk
of acquiring more than twenty infectious
diseases - from anthrax to varicella
zoster - can be substantially reduced in
HIV-positive individuals via vaccination,
some prior to, others after, exposure. In
addition, the guidelines address the use of
passive immunisation after exposure to
infectious diseases such as measles or
chicken pox.
The writing committee - which included
virologists, microbiologists, infectious
disease and HIV physicians, public health
specialists, and epidemiologists - was
headed by Dr Anna Maria Geretti,
consultant virologist at London's Royal
Free Hospital.
Here, she explains why the guidelines took
so long to produce, provides an overview of
the most important - and controversial -
issues, and discusses some practical
considerations, including who will pay for
and provide the various vaccines.
aids treatment update july 2006
Why the need for such
Now that people are living longer, and
for immunisation following exposure to
are often very well for extended periods
rabies. And then there are some areas
We realised that some important
of time, they need to be protected in
which are controversial and for which it
issues needed addressing. Recently,
the long term from infections that were
took a long time for the committee to
the Department of Health (DoH)
perhaps less of a concern previously.
achieve consensus. In fact, in some areas
revised the UK immunisation
For example, HIV-positive people now
the recommendations remain tentative,
guidelines for the general
often wish to travel to countries with a
which is why we are keen to receive
population[2], and although they
high risk of infections. Some people
feedback during the consultation period.
mention HIV frequently, the
also want to access jobs that may
For example, the benefits of
recommendations are not very
carry a risk of exposure and therefore
pneumococcus vaccination remain really
specific. The DoH had also consulted
require protection. An additional
with BHIVA about the possible use of
consideration is that a significant
the smallpox vaccine while developing
proportion of HIV-positive people may
Pneumococcus is responsible for
plans for dealing with a potential
have migrated to the UK in adult life
much of the bacterial pneumonia
bioterrorist attack. Since this is a live
and perhaps missed vaccinations that
seen in HIV-positive people, and can
vaccine that is contraindicated in
cause other illness, like meningitis.
are part of the routine childhood
HIV-positive people, they wanted to
A study from Uganda[3] raised
schedule. The DoH has issued
know what we thought about
doubts about its safety and
recommendations about ensuring
effectiveness, but other studies
mandatory HIV testing for people
adequate vaccine coverage in these
contradict this. How did you reach
who had been identified as needing
populations and HIV-positive people
the vaccine (i.e. front-line
should not be excluded if vaccination
With great difficulty! We had a
can be given safely. These were some of
prolonged discussion where all the
the factors that prompted us to
So, those were the starting points that
available evidence was discussed, and
develop the guidelines.
made us think about immunisation in
we examined the pros and cons. In the
general. We were also aware that
end we thought that the findings from
Your first presentation on the
potent anti-HIV therapy has changed
Uganda would not necessarily apply to
guidelines was at the BHIVA
the natural history of HIV infection.
meeting in Dublin in March 2005.
the UK, where most people who have a
First of all, improved immunity through
They were supposed to be made
low CD4 count would be started on
antiretroviral therapy means that the
available later that year. What made
anti-HIV therapy, thereby reducing the
overall efficacy of vaccination is now
it such a long and difficult process?
risk of pneumonia seen with the
greatly improved in HIV-positive
The lack of controlled data, both in
vaccine recipients in Uganda. However,
people. Another important
terms of susceptibility to infection and
although the vaccine may be beneficial
consideration is that improved
also how really effective these vaccines
in the UK, there are no well-controlled
immunity means that some vaccines
are in someone who has regained CD4
data to back this up and most of the
that were previously contraindicated
cells after starting anti-HIV therapy. For
evidence for a beneficial effect comes
because of safety concern (e.g. yellow
example, there are no good controlled
from small studies. That's why it has
fever, or the MMR -
data to determine the need for hepatitis
been so difficult to actually achieve a
measles/mumps/rubella - vaccine)
B boosters after successful vaccination,
consensus. We do recommend the
should now be reconsidered.
or for deciding on the optimal schedule
vaccine for HIV-positive people with a
aids treatment update july 2006
CD4 count above 200 cells/mm3 on
Preventing rabies is a classical
stable anti-HIV therapy. However, the
example of an infectious disease that
risk of pneumococcal disease is higher
ought to be dealt with differently in
in people with CD4 counts below 200
HIV-positive people. Our patients are
cells/mm3 who are not on anti-HIV
travelling more and more, and many
therapy which is why we say that
are travelling to countries where rabies
vaccination may be considered for HIV-
is still endemic - India, Pakistan,
infected persons with CD4 count below
Thailand, Vietnam. However, because
200 cells/mm3.
post-exposure prophylaxis for rabies
needs to be done differently compared
Since it is a live vaccine, the oral
to HIV-negative people - you may have
polio vaccine (OPV) is listed as one
to use more doses of the vaccine and
not recommended for HIV-positive
test for antibody responses more
people, especially since it has been
frequently - it makes sense to
discontinued in the UK. Why, then, is
recommend a preventative vaccine. In
it discussed in the guidelines?
fact, the rabies guidelines have taken a
Yes, it has been discontinued, so that
long time to write because they are so
is not a problem for those of us in the
complicated, and there's very limited
UK. But it may be a problem for
evidence to inform them. Along the
someone who travels, or who may
same lines, a traveller with HIV may
come into contact with someone from
want to consider a typhoid vaccine, and
those countries where it continues to
if in doubt about the risk, it may be
be used who may be shedding the
better to take the vaccine than not.
vaccine. So it's an indirect problem. In
addition some people from
You mentioned earlier that the
sub-Saharan Africa - where it is still
DoH consulted with BHIVA on the
being used - may come into contact
smallpox vaccine.
with this vaccine, and may even be
What recommendations did you
considering getting the vaccine if they
go back home. It's important for us to
At the moment the only people receiving
say that it should not be used in
the smallpox vaccine are those who have
HIV-positive people and give guidance
been identified in the UK to be the
on the management of people who
first-line response team in case of a
may come in contact with someone
bioterrorist attack. We felt that there
shedding the vaccine.
had to be some guidance in case an
HIV-positive person is asked to be part
Travel-related risks are covered
of that particular front-line team, or if
extensively in the guidelines. Rabies,
the hypothetical scenario of a
for example, is dealt with somewhatcontroversially:
bioterrorist attack becomes real. We say
you recommend that HIV-positive
that if someone has a real risk of
people travelling to high-risk areas
exposure to smallpox, then they should
receive a preventative rabies vaccine
be given the vaccine. However, if the risk
before they travel. Isn't this very
is only hypothetical, we recommend
different to what is recommended
against the vaccine because it's a very
for HIV-negative people?
poorly tolerated vaccine with a lot of
Overall the recommendations for travel
side-effects. It can be nasty even in
are the same as for HIV-negative
people who are HIV-negative and it
people. However, one should keep in
would never get approval for use
mind that for some HIV-positive people
nowadays! However, if there was a
the risk of infection and the
bioterrorist attack and there was a real
consequences of being infected may be
risk for HIV-infected patients, then we
more significant. Furthermore, responses
would recommend the vaccine, as the
to post-exposure immunisation may be
risk of vaccination would be less than the
suboptimal. These considerations
risk associated with the infection itself.
indicate that, provided the vaccine is
safe, one should have a lower threshold
Measles is relevant to many people
for recommending vaccination.
right now. Recent outbreaks have
aids treatment update july 2006
been reported in the UK, and it
There are tests that we have for certain
However, I think we need to involve
can cause serious illness in people
infections, like measles or polio, but not
GPs more and more in the care of our
with HIV. Given that the live
for all. Therefore in the absence of a
HIV-positive patients and this is
measles vaccine itself may cause
reliable history of vaccination it seems
certainly very important for addressing
illness in people with HIV, what do
preferable to consider vaccination, as
the issue of vaccinations. I have no
recommended in the DoH guidelines for
illusions that just by being registered
Measles in HIV-infected patients with
the general population.
with a GP and issuing a set of
poor immunity is a devastating
guidelines all recommended
infection. It can cause encephalitis
Who should shoulder the
immunisations would automatically be
(swelling of the brain) and pneumonia,
responsibility for investigating
given, because unfortunately we have
and has a high mortality rate. Given
vaccination histories and providing
examples from other areas of care
the current outbreak situation we
where things don't always happen as
definitely must make an effort now to
I think that patients should take some
they're supposed to in this field.
check that our patients are immune,
responsibility for keeping track of their
Certainly, as HIV physicians, we should
and - provided the CD4 count is above
vaccine records but HIV clinics should
liaise closely with the GPs and should
200 and the person is well - we should
actually take the lead position over
also place responsibility on our
give immunisation if they are not
these vaccinations. The ideal situation
patients for taking good care of their
immune. We are recommending in the
is that we assess the need for
health. Through this partnership it is
guidelines that if someone has no prior
immunisation through the HIV clinics
possible to ensure that the
history of vaccination, or infection with
because it's easier to control and
recommended vaccination courses are
measles, then they should be screened
monitor, and reliable information on
started and completed appropriately.
by doing a test - the measles IgG test -
clinical history and immune status is
and if found to be negative they should
available. The HIV clinics should run
What about travel-related vaccines?
be offered the vaccine. The same
all the necessary tests if indicated and
I think that who pays for and
applies for other childhood vaccines:
make the necessary recommendations,
administers travel-related vaccines is a
polio, diphtheria, tetanus. If you were
but they should then enlist the help of
different issue. It's probably more
born in the UK after 1962 you were
GPs whenever possible to actually
realistic to think that HIV-positive
probably vaccinated against these
administer the sort of vaccines that are
people will need to meet the cost if the
infections as a child. However, if you
routinely available through the NHS.
vaccine is needed for travel just as
were born before that, or outside of the
people without HIV have to pay for
All HIV-positive people don't have
UK at any time, you might actually not
these vaccines. If we are making the
GPs, and many of those that have
have a completed vaccination history
argument that HIV-positive people are
one are not comfortable disclosing
and may benefit from a new vaccine
their HIV status to them. It is not
well enough to travel to high-risk
always going to be possible for an
areas, and that they can have
HIV clinic to refer someone to
previously contraindicated vaccines
How you do determine whether
their GP to provide, for example,
because their immunity is okay, I can't
you've been vaccinated against
the MMR jab.
really see us being in a very strong
infectious diseases in the past if
position to argue that if someone
you can't remember and/or there
That was also a difficult dilemma for
decides that they want to travel and
us when writing the guidelines.
they need a vaccine, that they should be
entitled to have it for free based on
their HIV status.
further information
Please address questions and
The BHIVA immunisation guidelines
are for HIV-positive adults over the
age of 16. The Children's HIV
Association (CHIVA) produce
children and adolescents, available at
aids treatment update july 2006
Serious heartcondition still affecting
Switch from triple nukes,
even if you're doing well
An expert in pulmonary arterial hypertension (PAH) - a relatively
rare, but very serious, complication of HIV infection - is advising
An Italian study has found that people starting treatment
any HIV-positive individual who is feeling breathless for no
for the first time who take a triple nucleoside reverse
apparent reason to see their doctor to investigate whether PAH is
transcriptase inhibitor (NRTI) combination with abacavir
(Ziagen) as their third drug are significantly more likely toexperience a rebound in their viral load - even if they had
Pulmonary arterial hypertension causes blood pressure to rise in
achieved durable suppression of HIV - than those who
the arteries that carry oxygen-deprived blood away from the heart
take the non-nucleoside reverse transcriptase inhibitor
so that it can be replenished in the lungs. Incidence in the general
(NNRTI) efavirenz (Sustiva) as their third drug.
population is just one or two cases per million. Before potent
Current treatment guidelines say that a triple NRTI
anti-HIV therapy was available, it was estimated to be about
regimen - usually Trizivir which contains AZT, 3TC and
one-in-200 in people with HIV.
abacavir in one pill - should only be considered as a
Now, new research from France has found that PAH is no less
starting regimen in very occasional circumstances, for
common today than it was ten years ago. Last year, 7,648 HIV
example when TB medicine is also needed (since there are
patients from 14 centres across France were screened for PAH. Of
interactions with most other anti-HIV drug combinations)
739 found to be suffering from breathlessness - the most common
or when one pill once a day will make a significant
early sign of PAH - thirty-five were found to have PAH after further
difference to treatment adherence. This is because several
investigation: an incidence rate of almost one-in-200.
studies have found that triple NRTIs are not as potent as
combining two NRTIs with another class of drugs.
Lead author Dr Olivier Sitbon told the American Thoracic Society
International Conference, held in San Diego in May, that doctors
The Italian study wanted to see if patients who took
should have a low threshold for suspecting PAH if their patient
abacavir as a third drug, and who had initially achieved an
undetectable viral load, had an increased risk of
experiencing subsequent virological failure compared to
It is currently unknown why HIV can cause the pulmonary arteries
individuals taking efavirenz-based therapy. They observed
to become thickened and narrowed, leading to PAH. In addition,
744 patients who were starting anti-HIV therapy for the
PAH is seen in all groups of people with HIV infection, irrespective
first time and found that those who took abacavir as their
of the cause of infection or CD4 count. It is also a much more
third drug had an 85% greater risk of rebound than those
serious disease in HIV infection, and according to a Spanish study
who received efavirenz.
published in 2003, just over half of the individuals who developed
the condition died within three years.
Consequently, they recommend that people taking an
abacavir-containing triple NRTI combination should
New treatments for HIV-positive people with PAH are currently
change to a more potent anti-HIV regimen, even if they
being investigated, the most promising of which may be bosentan
have an undetectable viral load.
(Tracleer). This oral drug works by blocking the action of endothelin,a hormone which occurs in higher levels in people with PAH.
If only NRTIs can be used, however (due to TB drug
Although there was initial concern that bosentan may damage the
interactions, for example), current guidelines suggest that one
livers of HIV-positive people, new research in people taking the drug
possible option would be to add a fourth NRTI - tenofovir
for two years suggests that this is not necessary the case.
(Viread) - to Trizivir.
LGV continues to spread amongst HIV-positive gay men
Almost 350 cases of the sexually transmitted infection (STI) lymphogranuloma venereum (LGV) - a form of chlamydia usually
affecting the rectum - have now been diagnosed in the United Kingdom. Nearly all of the cases involved gay men, more than 75%
of whom were HIV-positive. Coinfection with other sexually transmitted infections is being seen at the same time: one-in-four had
another STI, and hepatitis C virus coinfection was seen in one-in-ten.
Epidemiological evidence suggests that LGV is transmitted via unprotected anal sex and fisting, which may also be the way the
hepatitis C is being transmitted sexually; again this is primarily affecting HIV-positive gay men.
Men who have sex with multiple partners at sex parties and sex clubs appear to be most likely to be diagnosed with LGV; 71% of
the men diagnosed so far reported this risk factor. LGV has now been seen in all parts of the UK, although most of the cases are
being diagnosed in London and Brighton: the Kobler Centre at the Chelsea and Westminster Hospital in London is reportedly
diagnosing ten new cases of LGV infection a week.
LGV can cause very unpleasant symptoms, similar to other bowel disorders, and may not be correctly diagnosed at first. In the
current outbreak, the commonest symptom has been proctitis - pain and inflammation in the anus and rectum. In some cases this
has been accompanied by swollen glands in the groin, and often by a discharge of mucus from the rectum (which can be bloody),
and constipation.
Condoms and latex gloves are very effective at preventing the transmission of STIs, including LGV, and, once correctly diagnosed,
the infection can be cured using a 21-day course of the oral antibiotic doxycycline.
Anti-HIV therapy adds thirteen years to post-AIDS survival
American researchers have calculated that today's highly effective anti-HIV treatments have added 160 months (thirteen years andfour months) to a person's life expectancy once they have been diagnosed with AIDS.
Using a computer model to determine the effect six periods of anti-HIV treatment had on the survival of people with HIV after an AIDSdiagnosis, they found that post-AIDS survival increased from 19 months prior to 1996 to 179 months - almost fifteen years - after 2003.
"This survival benefit greatly exceeds that achieved for patients with many other chronic diseases in the United States," they say.
better practice [page four]
news in brief [page twelve]
Society International Conference, San
Serious heart condition still affecting
Diego, abstract A728, 2006.
inhibitors in patients with initially
1. Elford J et al. Discrimination
LGV continues to spread amongst
suppressed viral loads. J Infect Dis
experienced by people living with
HIV-positive gay men
194 (online edition), 2006.
HIV. HIV Med 7 (supplement 1),
1. Sitbon O et al. Prevalence of
1. Ward H et al. Lymphogranuloma
Anti-HIV therapy adds thirteen years to
abstract P93, 2006.
pulmonary arterial hypertension in
post-AIDS survival
HIV positive outpatients in the
venereum (LGV) in the UK: national
immunisation guidelines [page eight]
Highly Active Antiretroviral Therapy
surveillance of a re-emerging disease.
1. Vermund SH. Millions of life-years
Era. American Thoracic Society
National Sexually Transmitted Disease
saved with potent antiretroviral drugs
International Conference, San Diego,
Prevention Conference, Jacksonville,
in the United States: a celebration, with
abstract 807, 2006.
late breaker, 2006.
challenges. J Infect Dis 194: 1-5,
Switch from triple nukes, even if you're
3. French N et al. 23-valent
2. Humbert, MD et al. Safety profile of
pneumococcal polysaccharide vaccine
bosentan in patients with pulmonary
in HIV-1 infected Ugandan adults:
arterial hypertension related to HIV:
1. Cozzie-Lepri, A et al. A comparison
double-blind, randomised and placebo
long-term results from the Tracleer
between abacavir and efavirenz as the
controlled trial. The Lancet 355:
PMS database. American Thoracic
third drug used in combination with a
2106-2111, 2000.
background therapy regimen of 2
aids treatment update july 2006
primary care at hiv clinics
are HIV clinics providing GP services? wonders Edwin J Bernard
In our lead article, Better Practice, it was argued that the integration of GPsinto caring for HIV-positive people is inevitable. NAM has been hearing froma lot of concerned HIV-positive people regarding this move. Since each HIVclinic has its own policies we thought we'd try and find out ourselves what ishappening. It hasn't been easy.
In May, we emailed a snapshot survey to seventeen HIV clinics across
the country. We received six responses at press time - four from clinics
in London, one from Manchester and one from Edinburgh.
Although their responses may not reflect what is happening at
your HIV clinic, the different policies and attitudes make for
Do you have a policy regarding your patients having GPs?
Central Middlesex Hospital, London: We encourage our patients to see aGP, or get registered with one.
Ealing Hospital, London: We try to provide a "holistic service" andtherefore end up treating many non-HIV-related conditions. This isparticularly so for the 40% of our patients who either don't have a GP ordo not allow us to contact their GP. We will resist any policy to changethis.
Queen Mary's Hospital, London: We have an ethos rather than a policy.
We encourage patients to have a GP and see their GP for non HIV-relatedcare.
further information
Mortimer Market Centre, London: Our policy is to advise all patients to
To find out more about the Patient
have a GP for all the usual reasons. We keep to General Medical Council
Advice and Liaison Service (PALS),
[GMC] guidance on confidentiality and communication.
which provides information on the NHS
North Manchester General Hospital: We have no policy as such, but we do
and health related matters and
encourage all patients to register with a GP and endeavour to find them
confidential assistance in resolving
one if they are not registered.
problems and concerns quickly, contact
your local PCT or NHS Direct on
Western General Hospital, Edinburgh: We have no written policy. We do
not see patients for non HIV-related care outside their routine HIVappointments. If patients pitch up without an appointment, they are
For more on the GMC's confidentiality
directed to acute receiving; if their problem is HIV related, they will be
aids treatment update july 2006
Do you have a policy regarding providing prescriptions for drugs that are not antiretrovirals, but may berequired due to HIV infection (e.g. lipid-lowering drugs, diabetes meds, antidepressants etc.)?
Central Middlesex Hospital: Yes. We are generally happy to prescribe these, except now that home delivery has
started, prescribing these drugs is more difficult. We will have to ask GPs to do more in the future.
Ealing Hospital: We prescribe everything on our hospital formulary through our HIV pharmacy annex. Prescriptions
are, therefore, free. This includes all the drugs you've listed as well as vaccines, malaria prophylaxis, etc.
Queen Mary's Hospital: We encourage people to be prescribed medication by the service which manages them. For example,
we don't manage their diabetes or increased lipids, so wouldn't prescribe those medicines, but we have policies on when to refer
on, where problems are related to HIV.
Mortimer Market Centre: Our clinic guide advises that patients should be encouraged to consult their GP for non HIV-relatedissues. If there is no GP or we have no consent for GP communication then we will prescribe for certain non HIV-relatedproblems, though we advise patients that the GP may be the most appropriate person to be doing the prescribing.
North Manchester General Hospital: As long as their antiretrovirals are also on the prescriptions, or the patient is known to beon antiretrovirals, then these kind of drugs are issued. We try to persuade patients to get GPs and eventually for them to takeover the care of and prescribing for non HIV-related conditions - but with backup phone numbers for discussions aboutinteractions etc.
Western General Hospital: We used to provide these meds via our hospital pharmacy but our pharmacy dispensing service isstretched and cannot cope. At our discretion, however, we would squeeze a non HIV prescription in, if the patient cannot get totheir GP.
Do you maintain a referral list ofHIV-friendly GPs, HIV-educated
How are you helping patients who cannot access a local
GPs, or GPs providing a locally
GP they trust and/or do not wish to disclose their HIV
enhanced service in your area?
status to their GP?
Central Middlesex Hospital: We used
Central Middlesex Hospital: We would prescribe for them, but
to, but not now really. There are no
our community workers will help them find GPs if possible.
local GPs who we think are specificallyHIV-unfriendly.
Ealing Hospital: We encourage patients to register and
use a GP. We do our best to make up for the lack of a GP if
Ealing Hospital: We know of GPs in
they do not wish to have or use a GP.
the area who we think are good,knowledgeable and non-judgemental.
Queen Mary's Hospital: If patients don't wish to disclose
Many years ago we ran a project with
their status to a GP, we discuss this with them and challenge
Hammersmith Hospital to help care
their beliefs regarding confidentiality. Where there is a genuine
for people with HIV, and thus had a
concern - for example, their neighbour works at the GP's practice
"special" liaison with some GP's in
- we would help them find a different GP, and occasionally people
have changed their GP to enable them to discuss their HIV.
Queen Mary's Hospital: We have a
Mortimer Market Centre: If patients can't find a suitable GP then we
community clinical nurse specialist to
tell them to contact the Patient Advice and Liaison Service (PALS)
assist with this. She knows which GPs
or NHS Direct and we provide the telephone number. We utilise the
have other HIV-positive patients, which
NHS website to give information on their nearest GP surgery. If they
reassures people who have concerns
do not trust their GP then we discuss the reasons behind this and at
about confidentiality which are more
the end of the day must respect the patient's wish for confidentiality
to do with their fear than reality.
as per GMC guidance.as long as the patient is making an informeddecision, then we respect this.
Mortimer Market Centre: No.
North Manchester General Hospital: We take over the prescribing
North Manchester General Hospital:
and, where possible, try and find the patient a ‘good' GP in their area.
Western General Hospital: Almost all of our patients have a GP who
Western General Hospital: Our
would provide primary care. If there is a problem, they are helped to
Edinburgh GPs are usually very helpful
choose another GP or use A&E services.
and we very rarely have problems. Weare lucky.
thanks to our funders
NAM's treatments information for people living with HIV
is provided free thanks to the generosity of:
Abbott Laboratories International & UK; Access 4;
Ajahma Charitable Trust; Alan & Nesta Ferguson
Charitable Settlement; Avexa; Birmingham PCT; The Body
Shop Foundation; Boehringer Ingelheim International &
UK; Bolton PCT; Bristol-Myers Squibb UK HIV &
Hepatitis; British HIV Association (BHIVA); Cleopatra
Trust; Corkery Group; Crusaid; Derek Butler Trust; Diana,
Princess of Wales Memorial Fund; Government of the
United Kingdom, Department of Health; East Sussex,
Brighton & Hove area PCTs; The Elton John AIDS
Foundation; Gilead International & UK; GlaxoSmithKline
UK; Healthsure Charitable Trust; Hugh Fraser Foundation;
International HIV/ AIDS Alliance; Janssen-Cilag; Lloyds
updated edition - july 2006
TSB Foundation for England and Wales; Lloyds TSB
Foundation for Northern Ireland; London HIV & GUM
Commissioning Consortium; MAC AIDS Fund; Merck
Sharp & Dohme UK & International; Newcastle PCT;
Whether recently diagnosed,
Norfolk PCT; Manchester city area PCTs; Miss Agnes H
it's absolutely great;
Hunter's Trust; Merton Social Services; Peter Moores
thinking about starting or
Foundation; Pfizer UK & International; Positive Action
so practical and easy
changing treatment or have
(GSK); Roche Products UK Hep C; Roche Products
International & UK; The Russell Trust; Salford PCT; Shire
lived with HIV for a long
personal stories really
Pharmaceuticals; South East Essex PCTs; South West
time, NAM's book Living
bring everything to
Essex PCTs; St. Stephen's AIDS Trust; Stockport Social
with HIV provides answers
Services; Thomas Sivewright Catto Charitable Settlement;
life. I am finding useful
Tibotec; Virco; West Sussex PCTs; Worcestershire PCT
to the questions you might
information that I
find yourself asking.
never knew and I can't
NAM would also like to acknowledge the generous
support of individual donors, and in particular Gavin Hay
believe that it is free!
Where to find out more about HIV
Find out more about HIV treatment:
This book is free to people
NAM's factsheets, booklets, directories and
personally affected by HIV,
website, keep you up to date about key
there is a charge for
topics, and are designed to help you make
your healthcare and HIV treatmentdecisions. Contact NAM to find out more
Order your copy today by phoning,
and order your copies.
emailing NAM or filling the order formbelow and returning it to the freepost
Information events in London
address listed.
On the last Monday of every month, an expertspeaker discusses an HIV treatment relatedtopic. Entry is free. The next topic is‘Feedback from the International AIDS
Please use this order form to get your FREE copy of Living With HIV
Conference, Toronto', and will be held on 21st
If you are a professional, please contact NAM directly. Contact details are shown below
August 2006. For more details, go towww.aidsmap.com/forums.
Visit our website for the latest news aboutHIV & AIDS and a fully searchabletreatments database and a complete list ofHIV treatment centres in the UK.
THT Direct PhonelineOffers information and advice to anyone
infected, affected or concerned about issuesrelating to HIV and sexual health.
We publish a range of information resources on HIV & AIDS.
Mon-Fri, 10am-10pm Sat-Sun, 12pm-6pm
Please tick this box if you would not like to be added to our mailing list.
We occasionally undertake fundraising campaigns to help support our work.
Please tick this box if you would not like to receive information about them.
i-Base Treatment Phoneline
please return this form to
A HIV Treatment phoneline; where you can
NAM, Freepost LON17995, London, SW9 6BR
discuss your issues with a treatment expert.
Mon-Wed, 12pm-4pm
Source: http://edwinjbernard.com/writing/161.pdf
Micro-Level Value Creation Under Managerial Short-termism ∗ Jonathan B. Cohn† University of Texas at Austin University of Texas at Dallas Wharton Research Data Services We present evidence that managers facing short-termist incentives set a lower threshold for accepting projects. Using novel data on new client and product an- nouncements in both the U.S. and international markets, we find that the marketresponds less positively to a new project announcement when the firm's managers haveincentives to focus on short-term stock price performance. Furthermore, textual analy-sis of project announcements show that firms with short-termist CEOs use more vagueand generically positive language when introducing new projects to the marketplace.Keywords: CEO Short-termism, Corporate Investment, CEO Compensation, CareerConcerns, Corporate Governance
MODULE PSYCHIATRIE (PSYCHOPATHOLOGIE) Dr Pierrette ESTINGOY _ (1er semestre 2008-2009) I ntroduction : généralités Introduction historique à la Psychiatrie. Approche clinique en psychiatrie A. Les grandes catégories de troubles psychiatriquesB. Entretien psychiatrique et démarche diagnostique en